On 9 June 2021 the Wooing Tree Estate Expert Consenting Panel invited comments on the application. The comments needed to be received by the EPA on 30 June 2021.

We received comments from 20 individuals and organisations which are listed below. Personal details have been redacted.

Comments received from individuals and organisations

Comments from Brent Anderson (PDF, 1.3MB)

Comments from Brett and Judy Chamberlain (PDF, 154KB)

Comments from David Cameron (PDF, 408KB)

Comments from Elizabeth Thomas (PDF, 2.2MB)

Comments from Fresh Choice (PDF, 581KB)

Comments from Heritage New Zealand (PDF, 545KB)

Comments from Jo Nieper (PDF, 252KB)

Comments from Leslie and Lynette Dick (PDF, 107KB)

Comments from Malcolm and Lorinda Lawson (PDF, 1.0MB)

Comments from the Minister for Arts, Culture and Heritage (PDF, 62KB)

Comments from Murray Taylor (PDF, 2.0MB)

Comments from Otago Regional Council (PDF, 285KB)

Comments from Patricia Patterson (PDF, 1.4MB)

Comments from Paul and Jocelyn Johnstone (PDF, 1.8MB)

Comments from River Rock Estate (PDF, 221KB)

Comments from Robyn MacKenzie (PDF, 2.8MB)

Comments from Te Rūnanga o Ngāi Tahu (PDF, 2.4MB)

Comments from The Gate and Keyrouz Holdings (PDF, 785KB)

Comments from Waka Kotahi NZ Transport Agency (PDF, 704KB)

The Chairman of Lakefield Estate provided comments on the application and the information was considered by the Wooing Tree Estate Expert Consenting Panel.

Read Minute 5 from the Wooing Tree Estate Expert Consenting Panel  

Comments from Tim Haughey Chairman of Lakefield Estate (PDF, 254KB)

Comments received from Central Otago District Council 

Central Otago District Council provided comments on the application and additional expert reports and information as listed below:

Comment form (PDF, 362KB)

Economic Review Report (PDF, 347KB)

Engineering conditions (PDF, 531KB)

Landscape comments (PDF, 707KB)

Legal submissions (PDF, 438KB)

Noise and vibration conditions (PDF, 117KB)

Planning evidence (PDF, 1.9MB)

Traffic (PDF, 1.3MB)

Urban design evidence (PDF, 3.7MB)

On 6 July 2021, the Council provided advice to support the noise and vibration conditions provided in its comments. 

Noise and vibration advice (PDF, 169KB)

Wooing Tree Property Development LP response to comments 

On 24 September 2021, the Wooing Tree Expert Consenting Panel issued Minute 14 regarding withholding information contained within the Veros Property report from Sean Haynes, provided by the applicant as part of their response to the comments received on the application. 

Minute 14 of the Wooing Tree Expert Consenting Panel (PDF, 96KB)

Vero Property report from Sean Haynes (PDF, 1.2 MB)

Wooing Tree Property Development LP responded to the comments from the invited parties on 28 July 2021:

Wooing Tree cover letter to EPA applicant's response to comments (PDF, 80KB)

A Legal Submissions Simpson Grierson Applicants response to comments (PDF, 710KB)

C Planning Statement Tattico Applicant response to comments (PDF, 538KB)

D1 Urban Design Evidence of Paddy Baxter Applicant response-to comments (PDF, 252KB)

D2 Urban Design Report attachments applicant response to comments (PDF, 13.1MB)

E Transport Statement Carriageway Applicant response to comments (PDF, 313KB)

F Economic Statement Market Economics Applicants response to comments (PDF, 185KB)

G Infrastructure Statement Paterson Pitts Applicants response to comments (PDF, 224KB)

H Noise and Vibration Report Marshall Day Acoustics Applicants response to comments (PDF, 209KB)

I Land Contamination Statement WPS Applicant response to comments (PDF, 12.7MB)

J Updated Suggested conditions of consent applicant response to comments (PDF, 342KB)

K Consultation Schedule applicants-response to comments (PDF, 118KB)

L Updated Subdivision Plans Adapt applicant response-to comments (PDF, 4.0MB)

M1 Hospitality Centre Site Plan FDA applicants response to comments (PDF, 588KB)

M2 Hospitality Centre plan FDA applicants response to comments (PDF, 4.2MB)

M3 Cellar Door Render 1 applicants response to comments (PDF, 4.1MB)

M4 Cellar Door Render 2 applicants response to comments (PDF, 4.6MB)

M5 Cellar Door Signage applicants response to comments (PDF, 1.3MB)

N Urban Design and Landscape Plan BaxterDesign applicants response to comments (PDF, 61KB)

O Engineering Plans Paterson Pitts applicants response to comments (PDF, 2.2MB)

O2 Revised Cross Section 17m Road applicants response to comments (PDF, 316KB)

P Earthworks Plans Paterson Pitts applicants response to comments (PDF, 7.8MB)

Q Staged Earthworks Planning Review applicants response to comments (PDF, 384KB)

R Land Contamination Planning Assessment applicants response to comments (PDF, 177KB)

Central Otago District Council cover email as part of applicants response to comments (PDF, 1.0MB)

Central Otago District Council reply to Wooing Tree revised proposal 20210712 as part of applicants response to comments (PDF, 145KB)

Central Otago District Council urban design response to Revised proposal 20210712 as part-of applicants response to comments (PDF, 686KB)

On 2 August 2021, Wooing Tree Property Development LP responded to comments provided by the Chairman of Lakefield Estate (Mr Tim Haughey) as provided for in Minute 5 from the Wooing Tree Estate Expert Consenting Panel.

Wooing Tree letter with response to comments from Lakefield Estate (PDF, 316KB)

Attachment to Wooing Tree response to comments from Lakefield Estate (PDF, 126KB)